Ex-NSA Brajesh Misra: Throw away Indo-US N-deal
by Smita Prakash
New
Delhi: Former Principal Secretary and National Security
Adviser to Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee Brajesh Mishra
today trashed the July 18, 2005 civilian nuclear deal signed
between India and the United States during Prime Minister
Dr. Manmohan Singh's landmark summit visit to that country.
In an exclusive interview to Asian News International, Mishra
said that the so-called historic deal of bilateral reciprocity
could end up compromising New Delhis strategic interests
and its status as a non-proliferating entity in the international
community.
"The July 18 Indo-U.S. deal should be thrown in the waste
paper basket," said Mishra, adding that had he been consulted
or been the Principal Secretary to the Prime Minister, he
would have cautioned Dr. Manmohan Singh about the long-term
implications of the deal. Elaborating further, Mishra said
that it would have been in New Delhi's interest to have
'some amount of understanding with the United States and
the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) on the issue of sharing
civilian nuclear energy.' "But, the way in which the July
18 deal has been expressed and elaborated, it indicates
America's intent of restricting our (India's) ability to
have more nuclear weapons, and it is bound to hit on our
strategic capability," he added. Recalling past deliberations
on India's nuclear policy, Mishra said that there had always
been a national consensus, but under the present administrative
dispensation, "our strategic capability and effort to have
minimum nuclear deterrence is sought to be curbed by the
Americans." "They (the Americans) want to have a credible
programme of submission of all our nuclear reactors to the
IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency) safeguards, and
if we do this, then we can never have credible nuclear deterrence."
When he was asked whether any artificial deadline was being
created, Mishra said: "The lure of the Bush visit (to India
in March) and it being successful has been equated with
the success of the Indo-U.S. nuclear deal." The present
scenario could only change if Washington unconditionally
accepted India as a nuclear power. "The idea of credible
minimum deterrence is flexible, as it would change with
the prevailing geo-political situation," the former Principal
Secretary to the Prime Minister said. On the ongoing composite
dialogue process between India and Pakistan, which was activated
immediately after the 12th SAARC Summit in January 2004,
Mishra said that the bilateral peace process is in jeopardy
because Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf has not fulfilled
the assurances that he had given to former Prime Minister
Vajpayee during the latter's visit to Pakistan in January
2004 on the sidelines of SAARC.
It
maybe recalled that Musharraf had given an undertaking to
Vajpayee that Pakistan's territory would not be used by
terrorists or for terrorist activity and only when this
goal was met, would Islamabad and New Delhi talk about restoration
of peace and maintenance of regional stability. According
to Mishra, the April 2005 Joint Statement issued on behalf
of President Musharraf and Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh
during the former's visit to New Delhi to watch a one-day
India-Pakistan international, completely nullified the understanding
of the January 2004 pact between Musharraf and Vajpayee.
That statement said that terrorism will not be allowed to
impede the peace process, as opposed to the earlier view
that bilateral talks would only take place after Pakistan
completed dismantled the terrorist structure on its territory.
"How can we believe Musharraf because one day he says that
terrorism will not be allowed from his territory, and on
another day he asks for demilitarizing Kashmir for terrorism
to stop? We are responsible for this situation because we
have given loopholes for Musharraf to walk through it,"
said Mishra. However, he said, that the dialogue process
should continue, but it "must be predicated with the assurance
that he had given, then only can it proceed."
Back
to Headlines
Go
To Top