Supreme Court dismisses plea for cross-verification of all EVM votes with VVPAT slips
The judgement:
The Supreme Court dismissed the petitions seeking verification of all the
votes cast on EVMs with VVPAT slips.
The apex court also rejected a plea to return to paper ballots.
The voter will not be allowed to take the VVPAT slip himself physically
and drop into the ballot compartment, which is currently being dropped there
automatically after the voter checks it through a screen.
The court said the ECI may explore the possibility of using an electronic
machine to count VVPAT slips.
The sealed containers containing the SLUs shall be kept in storerooms, with
the EVMs, (for) at least for 45 days post declaration of results, the court
said.
The burnt memory in the EVM microcontroller must be checked by a team of
engineers after results are declared if a candidate makes such a request,
the verdict stated.
"Blindly distrusting a system can lead to unwarranted suspicions," Justice
Dipankar Datta and Justice Sanjiv Khanna remarked.
OPINION: It is important that the random selection of the booths is
done after the EVM counting. It would also help to clear any lingering doubts
if the number of random booths is increased. The rest could be left to Lady
Luck!
NEW DELHI, Apr 26: The Supreme Court dismissed a batch of petitions on Friday
seeking cross-verification of all the votes cast through the EVMs (electronic
voting machines) with the VVPAT (Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail) paper slips
during counting. It also rejected a plea to return to the old paper ballot system
of voting.
The court also refused to allow the voters to put the VVPAT paper slips themselves
into the ballot compartment instead of them being dropped into it automatically
as is being done now.
The VVPAT slips are currently used to verify votes cast through the EVM only
in five randomly selected polling booths per constituency. The petition was
demanding to match up all the votes cast on EVM with the slips (100% verification).
The ECI argued that it matched EVM votes with more than 4 crore VVPAT slips
and so far there were no discrepancies found. The commission explained how it
is impossible to tamper with the EVMs and that the programme itself is copyrighted.
The VVPAT machine attached to the EVM prints out a slip of paper showing the
vote cast by a voter and drops it into a compartment below. The slip is visible
for seven seconds for the voter to check if the vote he cast has gone to the
candidate of his choice. These slips can be used and counted like ballot papers
and tallied with the candidate-wise total votes polled as shown by the EVM.
But at present this counter-verification is done only for five randomly selected
polling booths per constituency. This sampling is supposed to test the integrity
of system of machine voting.
The Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) and other petitioners alleged
that the EVM can be tampered with or even be pre-programmed to save majority
votes in favour of a particular candidate/party/symbol.
Advantages of EVM
There are quite a few advantages of using the EVM voting machine, especially
if transparency can be brought about. First, saving the paper. But even for
paper ballot there used to be complaints long ago that a Russian magic ink was
being used that does the trick of changing the mark in favour of the intended
candidate. There have been serious charges against the pro-active spymaster
of the universe for over a period of about three-fourths of a century. It is
now in public domain that they, using their latest home-grown technology, helped
Trump in winning the 2016 US presidential election but was preempted next time
as the Democrats smelt a rat and succeeded in changing the voting pattern heavily
in favour of postal ballot and early voting. A shocked Trump went violent and
still remains unstable.
Secondly, and this one is quite good, that there is no chance of the most common
dispute about the validity of a marking on a paper ballot by the voter in the
old system, holding up counting! There can never be an error when the candidate's
option is printed by a machine. Counting can be made easy.
Thirdly, saving the time. Results can be announced instantly. However, the
argument that election in India is the largest democratic exercise in the world
and we can no longer continue with the physical counting as in small countries
like France and Switzerlad, is fallacious. It was the most stupid thing for
the ECI to submit in the court that counting 100% VVPAT slips would pose a “great
difficulty” as it would take an hour to count the slips from one VVPAT alone.
Who are they kidding, the court?
TAILPIECE: It is true to say, if you know advanced computer programming,
that anything is possible through computing technology in the universe today
except for moving the mountains. And for that we don't need to wait for Quantum
to come. Even without programming knowledge, a teacher from her home computer
can correct her pupil's answers on his computer at his house. That is as simple
as that! As for the EVM, a simple mobile can be used from outside the booth
to rewrite the list/file the EVM is storing if you are familiar with the inside
of the machine. It is questionable whether a jurist who is defined as an expert
in the common laws formulated by the politicians, and the legal practices, by
virtue of just being that jurist is competent to express opinions on these technological
issues.
Apart from cash, Gill had also taken three planes as bribe and two of them
were leased out to Redbird Aviation Academy. With the result, flying
schools compromised on safety requirements and trainers met with
accidents several times.
Five people were arrested from a banquet hall in Sector 51 Noida on Thursday
where they were called to hold a rave party in a trap laid by the animal
rights group, PFA. They named Yadav but he was not present.
Betting through Dubai-based Mahadev Book in India is conducted through a countrywide network. Probes reveal that the online gambling is worth several millions and top politicians, officials and celebs have been beneficiaries.
TAILPIECE: Polling dates for some States are round the corner. Top
politicians have begun their acrimonious debate who looted more, even as
Mahadev is washing their dirty laundry in the open ghat. Come what may,
one needs to seize power to amass "thy wretched pelf!" One simple
question is, why else one should spend lakhs or crores to get elected! A
question every Indian should ask to oneself at least once a day!
His inaction amounts to defeating the rights of the people of the State to
welfare measures sought to be implemented through the Bills, the Kerala
Government's petition submitted, while the State of Tamil Nadu remarked
that its "Governor is acting as a political rival."
Tailpiece: Coming up back to back, the petitions in their totality seem to question the provision of Raj Bhavan, and not motives of a Governor as a
person.
Hundreds of cars piled up behind the wreckage of crashes occurring one
after other in backing up - continuous crashes to the rhythm of metallic
clanks and bangs back to back. According to reports, some ops required
'Jaws of Life' to pull apart the mangled cars to save lives inside.
The pilots struggled with Emerson to thwart a shut-off as he reached for
the T-handles (see pix). Later he admitted to police he had taken
psychedelic mushrooms and had a "nervous breakdown."
Doctors reasoned how the incidence of heart attacks is spiking over time and
advise the simple way to play safely is to take a break and rehydrate
yourself.
But how come ten people, including children, die of cardiac arrest at
Garba in 24 hours, and that at different places of Gujarat? Garba had been going on
for six days, and every year it is celebrated.
Shocking news from the UK: Leading grocers have started bribing policemen with free food and drinks to persuade them to take action against shoplifters.
Shoplifting has risen by about 27 per cent in 10 major cities across the UK
this year. The cost of retail crime last year was $2.15 billion. Besides, “We
are seeing organised gangs threatening staff with weapons and emptying
stores," Helen Dickinson, chief executive of the British Retail Consortium,
said. Data shows that the police failed to respond to 73 per cent of serious
retail crimes that included assault and abuse of workers, apart from
shoplifting.
Harris said hip-hop is “the ultimate American art form” that “shapes every
aspect of American popular culture.” “Hip-hop culture is American
culture,” she said in a talk at her official residence at the US Naval
Observatory in Washington, D.C.
The social media had mixed reaction. There was much appreciation that
she dances better than any VP in American history. But some called her
"moves" as “cringe” while others did not like her pink pants - "pink pants
don’t look good.” In fact, her ensembles have always been incongruous.
"Let’s see how the (Governor's) Vice-Chancellors are given salary."
Mamata's extreme statements will put the Marxist Government in Kerala,
which is also facing similar issues, to shame. Has she begun the
countdown for a war on the streets?
It's true Mamata has come to see a conspiracy to demolish the established systems across the country, but lacks the ability to foresee what exactly is being pushed.
Brandishing a sword, Mahant Paramhans told reporters on Tuesday he
himself will behead MK Stalin's son for his remarks against Sanatan
Dharma in case nobody came forward to accept his offer he made in his
video. Udhayanidhi reacted to the saint's Monday video, "I will speak
more. I am the grandson of the artist who put his head on the rail track for
Tamil Nadu."
Somanath elaborated, "I am an explorer. I explore the Moon. I explore the inner
space. So it's a part of the journey of my life to explore both science and
spirituality. So I visit many temples and I read many scriptures. So try to find the
meaning of our existence and our journey in this cosmos. So it's a part of the
culture that we are all built to explore, find out the inner self as well as outer
self. So for the outer, I do science, for the inner I come to temples." (See videos)
Rao the mathematical legend had fathered the path-breaking Rao-Blackwell
theorem, one of the most important theorems in mathematical statistics, at the
age of 25. That brought him global fame. He is also famous for his Cramér-Rao
Bound inequality theorem relating to quality of estimators in statistics which has
had a profound bearing on applications of modern economics and several other
diverse fields. Simply put, with the pioneering statistician computation became a
tool to analyse even socio-economic challenges of modern times.
The alleged incident has received such a flash publicity that a standardised
city's hugely middle class population will have second thoughts about eating
outside for some time. Now everything on the table looks suspicious!
“All subjects directly connected to the people should be shifted to the State List. Particularly the subject of education. Only if this is done can cruel exams like NEET be abolished,” Stalin said. Education was moved from the State List to the Concurrent List with the 42nd Constitution Amendment made by the Central Government in 1976.
Decentralisation has been at the core of Tamil politics since the times of CN Annadurai. Stalin indicated there will be political changes in the offing.
TAILPIECE: While the Centre and the States are at loggerheads, it takes a
different cognitive acumen to know that entrance tests are not the way for
students' admission to courses.
As recently as Tuesday Craig Robertson had posted on Facebook: "Perhaps
Utah will become famous this week as the place a sniper took out Biden the
Marxist." Biden was scheduled to make his first visit to Utah as President
Wednesday afternoon.
Maruti is recalling 87,599 S-Presso and Eeco vehicles to inspect and possibly
replace parts in the steering system. All reputed companies around the
world do recall their products when a defect comes to light.
Meanwhile, a question arises why just in about a year so many accidents have
taken place involving Mercedes sent to India while the car has won safety awards
abroad? In most cases, the vehicle collided with divider, while manoeuvring a
turn. Was there a split second delay in the steering system coming to a grip
when at high speed? Did anybody in India bother to study a pattern in several
of these accidents that took place one after other?
Former Tata Sons chairman Cyrus Mistry died when his Mercedes-Benz-SUV hit
a divider in Gujarat. Cricketer Rishabh Pant's Mercedes-Benz-SUV rammed a divider
in Uttarakhand and smashed. It went up in flames but he escaped with injuries.
Brother of PM Narendra Modi, Prahlad Modi's Mercedes-Benz-SUV met with a similar
accident in Mysuru. And many more.